Skip to Content

Get a FREE assessment of your rental property. Start here!

Get a FREE assessment of your rental property. Start here!

Are You Overpaying for Landlord Insurance

A necessity to owning a rental property is having a quality and reliable landlord insurance policy. A little research can save you money in the long run so that you can compare agencies and your rate to those available to you.  You may be paying too much for your insurance. The problem is, it can be hard to know whether you’re overpaying or not unless you know how to compare insurance policies like the pros do. We want to give you the tools so that you know what to look for in choosing your landlord insurance agency, we can ensure that you are getting the coverage you need at the best available price. 

When choosing a landlord insurance policy, it’s important to first decide whether you want to spend the time contacting individual insurance carriers or to have an independent insurance broker do it for you. If you choose to contact each carrier directly, you can get first-hand quotes and information either over the phone, online, or sometimes in person. An independent insurance broker may also have a local office, but they will sift through a multitude of carrier options for you and then present the ones they feel are the best for your situation. They also have a wealth of industry knowledge about the company’s reputation and stability of different insurance carriers, things that the carriers themselves may or may not not tell you.

 Once you’ve chosen your research method, you can start collecting and comparing insurance policy quotes. The first and most obvious thing to compare is the price. However, it’s important to note that the lowest priced policy may not be the best value for your money and is important to look for what they are providing you. This is because cheaper prices may mean less coverage, poor customer service, or as is often the case, is used as a lure to get your business before dramatically increasing your rate a few months later. Before comparing policies, make sure that each one has equal amounts of coverage, and that the coverage described meets both your needs and any state or local requirements.

The value of a landlord insurance policy goes beyond the price. For example, the quality and speed of the customer service the carrier offers are other important elements to consider before deciding which way to go. A reputable carrier should offer 24/7 claims reporting and access to live support staff, so that the unpredictable nature of your rental can receive service in a timely and efficient manner. In the event of an accident or disaster, you need to know that your insurance carrier will be responsive and take immediate action to help you pay expenses and make repairs as efficiently as possible. The size, stability, and age of the company should also be included in your comparison, these are strong indicators of how strong and reliable the agency will be as your landlord insurance provider.

With a good understanding of how to choose a landlord insurance policy, the next big question is when or how often. As a business expense, rental property insurance should be shopped annually for both quality and price. If you haven’t done a detailed cost comparison on your landlord insurance policy in a while, you might be surprised at changes.  Just as with your changing of tenants and the changing of laws, these agencies change coverage and pricing. Checking your insurance policy every year might seem like a lot of work, but it is one aspect of real estate investing that you simply cannot afford to neglect and you will be glad once you see how much you can be saving from your rental expenses. 

When questions about landlord insurance policies arise, the professionals at Real Property Management can help. We can connect our property investors with insurance professionals who offer the best quality policies at competitive rates. By using industry best practices, we assist in providing quality long-term rental homes a streamlined, profitable endeavor.

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.